The Downfall of Facebook Part I – Ads on Facebook

This is part one of a multipart article series looking at the current landscape of the social media platform Facebook and its effect on New Zealand SME businesses.

Introduction

Facebook, once the titan of social media platforms, is facing a noticeable decline in user satisfaction and engagement. For many users, the experience of scrolling through their feed has become dominated by ads and recommended pages, overshadowing the content from pages and people they follow. This shift has significant implications for businesses, particularly in New Zealand, where small businesses rely on Facebook for marketing and customer engagement. In this article, we will explore the current state of Facebook, suggest improvements for Meta, and provide warnings from a business perspective about the platform’s future viability.

Mars Digital, a trusted name in digital marketing in New Zealand, has been navigating the social media landscape since its founding in 2018. Our expertise, rooted in the extensive experience of our founder, Matthew Edwards (that’d be me), who has been involved with social advertising for over a decade, places us in a unique position to analyse and critique the shifts within Facebook’s ecosystem. Since its inception, Mars Digital has been committed to helping New Zealand businesses harness the power of social media, enabling them to reach broader audiences and achieve their marketing goals.

The Importance of Social Media for New Zealand Businesses

New Zealand’s business landscape is characterised by a vast number of small to medium-sized enterprises (SMEs). According to Statistics New Zealand, SMEs make up 97% of all businesses in the country, highlighting their critical role in the economy. These businesses often operate with limited resources, particularly when it comes to marketing budgets. This financial constraint has historically made social media platforms like Facebook an attractive option due to their ability to provide substantial reach at a relatively low cost.

Social media platforms have democratised marketing, offering businesses the ability to engage with their audience without the need for massive advertising budgets. For New Zealand businesses, this has meant the ability to compete on a level playing field with larger companies, using creativity and strategic targeting to reach potential customers.

The Changing Dynamics of Facebook

In the early days of Facebook, the platform offered unparalleled opportunities for businesses to connect with their audience. Organic reach allowed businesses to engage with followers without significant investment in advertising. However, over the years, the dynamics of Facebook have changed dramatically. The introduction of algorithms that prioritise paid content has led to a substantial decrease in organic reach. Today, businesses must invest heavily in paid advertising to achieve the same level of visibility that was once possible for free.

This shift has profound implications for New Zealand businesses. As marketing budgets remain tight, the increasing cost of Facebook advertising can be a significant burden. For many small businesses, the return on investment (ROI) from Facebook marketing is diminishing, leading to questions about the platform’s long-term viability as a marketing tool.

The Rise of Advertisements and Recommended Content

One of the most significant changes users and businesses have noticed on Facebook is the overwhelming presence of advertisements and recommended content. The user experience has shifted from being a place to connect with friends and follow favourite pages to a platform inundated with ads. This change has not only frustrated users but has also impacted businesses negatively.

About the Author

Founder

I’ve always believed that each business is unique. Bringing this view to Mars Digital means we take the time to understand you and your business before going away, doing the research and coming back to you with our thought out recommendations and the reasoning behind them.

For me, it’s all about building a mutually beneficial partnership.

Our Work

Destination Orewa Beach
Destination Orewa Beach

Destination Orewa Beach

Comprehensive Care
Comprehensive Care

Comprehensive Care

Coast Residential
Coast Residential

Coast Residential

Cain Built
Cain Built

Cain Built

Daylite Skylights
Daylite Skylights

Daylite Skylights

3D Online
3D Online

3D Online

JC Project Consulting
JC Project Consulting

JC Project Consulting

Taxi Tax
Taxi Tax

Taxi Tax

Trident Electrical & Air Conditioning
Trident Electrical & Air Conditioning

Trident Electrical & Air Conditioning

Zakmir
Zakmir

Zakmir

Hibiscus Coast Panel Beaters
Hibiscus Coast Panel Beaters

Hibiscus Coast Panel Beaters

Stella Beauty
Stella Beauty

Stella Beauty

Osteo Clinic
Osteo Clinic

Osteo Clinic

For users, the excessive presence of ads can lead to decreased engagement and time spent on the platform. When users feel that their feed is cluttered with irrelevant ads and recommended pages, they are more likely to disengage or reduce their usage of Facebook. This trend is concerning for businesses that rely on the platform to reach their audience, as lower user engagement directly translates to reduced effectiveness of their marketing efforts.

From a business perspective, the decline in organic reach means that even followers who actively choose to follow a page are less likely to see its content. This forces businesses to increase their ad spend to maintain visibility. However, this approach is not sustainable for many small businesses in New Zealand, where marketing budgets are already stretched thin.

The New Zealand Context

New Zealand businesses face unique challenges in the digital marketing landscape. The country’s geographic isolation and smaller local markets necessitate innovative approaches to reach broader audiences. Social media has been a vital tool in this regard, allowing businesses to transcend physical boundaries and connect with customers both domestically and internationally.

However, as the cost of advertising on platforms like Facebook continues to rise, New Zealand businesses are feeling the strain. The traditional advantage of social media as a low-cost, high-reach marketing tool is eroding. For businesses that have relied on organic reach to build their brand and engage with customers, the current state of Facebook is particularly troubling.

The Need for Change

For Facebook to remain a viable platform for New Zealand businesses, changes are necessary. Meta, Facebook’s parent company, must recognise the growing dissatisfaction among users and businesses and take steps to address these issues. There are several areas where improvements could be made to restore balance and enhance the user experience while also supporting businesses.

The Role of Mars Digital

At Mars Digital, we understand the critical role that social media plays in the marketing strategies of New Zealand businesses. Our experience and expertise enable us to provide valuable insights and solutions to navigate the changing landscape. We advocate for a more balanced approach to social media marketing, one that leverages both paid and organic strategies to achieve sustainable growth.

As we continue to support our clients through these challenges, we emphasise the importance of diversification. While Facebook remains a powerful tool, relying solely on one platform can be risky. Businesses should consider expanding their digital marketing efforts to include other social media platforms, search engine optimisation (SEO), content marketing, and email marketing. By diversifying their marketing strategies, businesses can mitigate the risks associated with changes in any single platform.

Conclusion

The current trajectory of Facebook, with its emphasis on ads and recommended content, is concerning for both users and businesses. For New Zealand businesses, which often operate with limited marketing budgets, the increasing cost of Facebook advertising and the decline in organic reach are significant challenges. To remain a valuable marketing tool, Facebook must adapt to the evolving needs of its users and business clients.

As we delve deeper into this article series, we will explore specific suggestions for Meta to improve Facebook and provide a detailed analysis of the implications for businesses. Our goal is to offer actionable insights that can help New Zealand businesses navigate the changing social media landscape and continue to thrive in the digital age. Stay tuned as we unpack the complexities and offer solutions to ensure that Facebook remains a platform that supports both users and businesses effectively.

Marketing out of this world